Are you taxed on the sale of your primary residence?
- coraliefortin076
- Aug 1
- 8 min read
Selling a residential property is often a pivotal moment in a homeowner's life. Whether it's to make room for a new phase of life, move to an environment more suited to your needs, or simply enjoy the value gained over the years, it's crucial to fully understand the tax implications surrounding this transaction. At Plan Maison Québec, we assist hundreds of homeowners each year in planning their construction and renovation projects, and we know that tax issues are a common concern.
Contrary to what many people think, the sale of a house, cottage, or even a garage can, in some cases, result in a tax bill if certain conditions are not met. Ignoring your tax obligations could cost you dearly. That's why we've prepared this comprehensive article to shed light on the situations in which tax is required, possible exemptions, and mistakes to avoid to stay in compliance with the tax authorities. So, are you taxed when selling your primary residence?
Capital Gains Fundamentals
When you sell a property, the government generally considers you to have realized a capital gain if the sale price exceeds the initial acquisition cost. This gain corresponds to the difference between the sale price of your property and its purchase price, to which you can add certain eligible expenses such as:
notary fees
real estate brokerage fees
applicable taxes
as well as major improvement expenses incurred over time.
However, cosmetic renovations should not be confused with structural improvements.
At Plan Maison Québec, we can help you properly document and structure this work, especially if you have used our services to plan expansions or renovations.
At both federal and Quebec levels, only half of the capital gain is taxable. This means that you are not taxed on the entire capital gain, but only on 50% of it. This income is added to your other sources of income for the year and is therefore taxed at your marginal tax rate. However, if the sale of the property qualifies for the principal residence exemption, this tax can be avoided entirely.
It's important to note that if the sale of the property qualifies for the principal residence exemption, you generally won't be able to deduct it, except in certain specific situations, such as a business or professional activity. This reinforces the importance of having a clear understanding of the true value of your property and its successive uses, whether for personal residence, partial rental, or mixed use. At Plan Maison Québec, we always encourage you to keep careful track of all changes made to your property, as they can play a significant role in calculating your capital gain (or loss).
The main residence exemption
One of the most popular tax benefits for homeowners in Canada is the principal residence exemption. In many cases, this measure allows you to avoid paying tax on the capital gain realized when selling your home. To fully benefit from this exemption, certain conditions must be met. First, you must have lived in the property as your principal residence for all the years you owned it, or have designated it as such for each year you owned it.
It is essential to understand that in Canada, you can only designate one property as your principal residence for a given year, even if you own multiple residences (townhouse, cottage, condo). Therefore, tax planning is sometimes necessary to determine which of your properties will generate the greatest tax savings upon disposal. At Plan Maison Québec, we recommend consulting a tax advisor when you own multiple properties or if you intend to sell a secondary property, such as a cottage.
For the exemption to be recognized, the declaration must be filed correctly. Since 2016, it's no longer enough to simply check a box or omit mentioning the sale on your tax return. You must complete the required forms, such as the federal T2091(IND) and the Quebec TP-274, in addition to Schedule 3 of your tax return. If you fail to file this declaration, you could lose your right to the exemption, even if you were eligible, and face penalties. A costly oversight, but one that can be avoided.
When the exemption does not apply
There are several scenarios where the principal residence exemption does not apply. For example, if you used part of your property for business or rental purposes, you may have to include a portion of the capital gain in your taxable income. The Canada Revenue Agency determines the taxable portion based on the space used for rental or business operations. If more than 50% of your home was used for these purposes, you may not be eligible for the exemption, or at least not all of it.
Another case to consider concerns so-called "rush sales." Since January 2023, a new tax rule has come into effect in Canada: if you sell a property you owned for less than 12 months, this transaction is automatically presumed to be of a commercial nature, unless you can demonstrate a life event justifying the quick sale:
illness
death
divorc
job loss
etc.
In this case, the profit is fully taxable as business income, with no possibility of claiming the principal residence exemption.
Finally, if you own multiple residences and have already designated another as your principal residence for certain years, you may have to pay tax on a portion of the gain. This often happens with cottages, which appreciate in value quickly and whose sale is sometimes considered more tax-efficient than selling your principal residence in the city. This calculation should be done with the help of a professional, but it must be planned in advance, especially if you intend to sell several properties in a short period of time.
Your reporting obligations
Even if you qualify for the principal residence exemption, you are required to report the sale of your home on your tax return. This point is essential and often misunderstood. Failure to report the sale can result in heavy penalties and even cause you to lose your right to the exemption, meaning you will have to pay tax on a gain that could have been exempt.
In concrete terms, you must complete Schedule 3 of your federal return, Form T2091(IND) to indicate that you are designating the property as your principal residence, and Form TP-274 for Quebec. It's not enough to simply mention the sale verbally to your accountant or notary; everything must be precisely documented. These forms request information such as the purchase date, the sale date, the sale price, the purchase price, and the period during which the home was designated as your principal residence.
If you have used Plan Maison Québec to carry out extensions or major renovations, make sure you have kept the invoices and plans, as they may allow you to increase your adjusted acquisition cost, thus reducing your taxable gain.
It should also be noted that willful or repeated failure to file a report can result in tax penalties of up to $8,000, or even more in certain situations. In addition, failure to file a report extends the period during which tax authorities can review your file indefinitely. This exposes you to audits and adjustments several years after the transaction.
Possible deductions related to the sale
When it comes to selling a house, cottage, or garage, many homeowners don't realize that there are certain expenses directly related to the transaction that can influence the calculation of the capital gain, and therefore potentially reduce the amount of tax payable. At Plan Maison Québec, we know that these financial aspects are essential for planning your real estate project with confidence.
First, it's important to understand that the calculation of the capital gain begins with the difference between the sale price and the purchase price of the property, but this calculation can be adjusted based on costs incurred during the transaction. For example, real estate brokerage fees (commission paid to the agent or broker who facilitated the sale), legal fees incurred to prepare the sales documents, and notary fees are considered eligible expenses that increase the adjusted cost base of your property. By increasing this cost base, you reduce the taxable capital gain.
Beyond these direct selling costs, expenses for major improvements to your home play an equally crucial role. Unlike routine repairs or maintenance work, which are not taken into account, renovations or additions that increase the property's value or extend its lifespan can be added to the initial acquisition cost.
This includes, for example, adding a bedroom, finishing a finished basement, building a garage, or even a major kitchen or bathroom renovation. If you have hired Plan Maison Québec to design renovation or expansion plans, it is strongly recommended that you keep all documents, invoices, and municipal permits, as this evidence is required to justify these expenses to Revenu Québec and the Canada Revenue Agency.
Another often overlooked point concerns certain additional costs, such as the costs associated with obtaining building or planning permits required to complete the work. These costs can, under certain conditions, be included in the acquisition cost and thus reduce the capital gain. At Plan Maison Québec, we help you navigate these regulatory aspects so you can maximize your tax benefits.
It's also worth mentioning that certain moving expenses associated with the sale may be deductible if you moved for work or school reasons, particularly if the new workplace or educational institution is at least 40 kilometers from your old residence. In this case, eligible moving expenses may include transportation and storage costs, as well as expenses related to the sale of your old home. These deductions reduce your overall tax burden.
However, you must remain vigilant: for these deductions to be accepted by the tax authorities, it is essential to carefully keep all receipts, invoices, and contracts relating to the sale, renovation work, and moving expenses. In the event of an audit, these documents will serve as essential evidence to support the amounts declared. Furthermore, certain expenses must be clearly distinguished between what constitutes an improvement (capitalizable) and what constitutes a current expense (non-deductible).
At Plan Maison Québec, we often advise our clients to take a proactive approach to record keeping. This means archiving not only invoices, but also quotes, correspondence with contractors, architectural plans, and even before-and-after photos of the work. This rigor allows you to have a clear view of the property's evolution and optimize tax benefits at the time of sale.
In summary, even if the sale of your principal residence is generally exempt from capital gains tax, you should not overlook the costs and expenses that can influence this calculation. In cases where the property does not qualify for the full exemption, these deductions can significantly reduce the taxable amount.
Proper planning and accurate documentation are therefore essential, and at Plan Maison Québec, we are ready to assist you in this process, whether for the design of your projects or to advise you on the tax aspects of the sale.
Special cases to consider
Some real estate transactions do not take the form of a traditional sale. These may involve a transfer between family members, a gift, or a transfer upon death. In each of these cases, specific tax rules apply. For example, gifting a house to a child is treated for tax purposes as a disposition at market value. Even if no money is exchanged, the parent may have to pay tax on the capital gain.
Upon death, the deceased's property is deemed to have been sold at its fair market value immediately before death. The executor must then calculate the capital gain or loss and determine whether the principal residence exemption may apply. In some cases, it may be advantageous to designate the secondary residence as the principal residence for one or more years if this reduces the overall tax payable by the estate.
Such decisions require careful documentation and sound advice. That's why, at Plan Maison Québec, we encourage our clients to keep their records up to date, especially when making major changes to their property, such as expansions, conversions, or new construction. Proper documentation can make the difference between a straightforward transaction and a complex tax situation.
Conclusion : Can you be taxed on the sale of your primary residence?
Selling a property, whether it's a house, a cottage, or a garage, may seem simple at first glance, but it sometimes hides complex tax implications. Between eligibility requirements for the principal residence exemption, rules surrounding rushed sales, mandatory declarations, and special cases, it's easy to make a costly mistake.
At Plan Maison Québec, our mission goes far beyond creating customized plans. We support our clients through every stage of their real estate project, from planning to completion, including a clear understanding of the tax impact of their decisions. Whether you're about to sell your property or planning a new construction or renovation project, we're here to guide you.
Ready to get started?
Comments